Fair Districts = Fair Elections
  • Home
  • Take the End Gerrymandering Pledge
  • About
  • What is Gerrymandering?
  • Media
  • Events
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Voter Registration
  • Request a Speaker
  • Resources
  • History of Reform
  • Endorsements
  • Privacy Policy

The US Supreme Court’s new gerrymandering case & what it means for Ohio

6/20/2017

16 Comments

 
By Carrie Davis, League of Women Voters of Ohio

Many of us have been eagerly watching an important gerrymandering case out of Wisconsin, Gill v. Whitford.

Yesterday - On Monday, June 29 - the US Supreme Court announced that they would hear Gill during the new term beginning in October 2017.

What the Wisconsin gerrymandering case is all about:
This is an exciting case to watch for redistricting reformers. While the US Supreme Court has said that it’s possible for excessive partisan gerrymandering (drawing districts to strongly favor a political party) to cross the line and be unconstitutional, the high court has never set a legal standard defining where that line might be. That’s where Gill v. Whitford comes in.

The Campaign Legal Center, who brought the case, proposes a numeric formula for measuring political gerrymandering. They call it “the efficiency gap.”

According to this paper by the Brennan Center, “the efficiency gap counts the number of votes each party wastes in an election to determine whether either party enjoyed a systematic advantage in turning votes into seats. Any vote cast for a losing candidate is considered wasted, as are all the votes cast for a winning candidate in excess of the number needed to win.”

In other words, if a state is heavily gerrymandered to create “safe seats” that one party will win by a landslide, those “wasted votes” will have a higher efficiency gap score – and, according to the Gill plaintiffs, rise to the level of an unconstitutional partisan gerrymander.

What this means for Ohio:
Ohio suffers from the same problem of having districts drawn to create safe seats that all but guarantee which party will win.

LWV Ohio’s 2015 report “Predictable Results II” documents how Ohio’s state and federal legislative districts overwhelmingly create predictable safe seats. (The forthcoming third edition of LWVO’s Predictable Results report, which incorporates 2016 election results, is being finalized and will be available soon.)

If the US Supreme Court decides to accept the Gill case’s invitation to establish a legal standard for what constitutes an excessive partisan gerrymander that unconstitutionally encroaches on voters’ rights to choose who represents them, that would prohibit any such future extreme partisan gerrymanders and could open the door to challenging existing maps in other states that also cross the line.

While Gill is an important case, it does not impact plans to pursue the Fair Congressional Districts for Ohio ballot proposal. Here’s why:
While Gill has the potential to strike a critical blow to partisan gerrymandering, that only impacts one part of needed reform to the redistricting process.

It does not address other aspects of gerrymandering that our ballot issue does:
  • Who draws the map - The Fair Districts proposal requires maps to be drawn by a bipartisan commission and votes from both parties are required to approve a map.
  • Not splitting communities – The Fair Districts proposal keeps communities whole by minimizing the ability to split up counties, municipalities and townships.
  • Compactness – Ohio currently has Congressional districts that include a narrow line along Lake Erie (district 9), a multi-hour drive from Portsmouth almost to Youngstown (district 6), and numerous other oddly-shaped districts. The Fair Districts plan requires districts to be compact.
  • Representational fairness – This means that the proportion of districts winnable by a party should mirror the proportion of votes that party receives. As opposed to our current map where one party has 75% of the seats and the other has 25% of the seats, even though statewide Ohio vote totals per party have been in the 50-50 to 60-40 range.
  • Transparent process – The Fair Districts proposal will require the entire redistricting process to be transparent and accountable, so the public can see if the rules are truly being followed.
The bottom line:  Gill v. Whitford is an incredibly important case, and we sincerely hope the Court takes this opportunity to draw a line to prohibit extreme partisan gerrymandering. However, true redistricting reformers know more is needed. We need to the strengthen the whole process, and that is just what the Fair Congressional Districts for Ohio proposal will do.

So keep passing those petitions and collecting signatures! With any luck, the Court will strike a blow against gerrymandering next term and Ohio voters will do the same when they vote yes on our ballot issue!

16 Comments
Carol Romie
6/21/2017 03:26:52 pm

Reply
do my uni assignments link
7/11/2017 10:02:42 am

The U.S supreme court is completely different from the supreme courts of other countries. As the supreme court is introducing the new ways of fighting the case in the easiest way. As per the decision it is sure that the final call is always depended on the supreme announcement.

Reply
Online solution for business assignment help link
9/10/2017 08:35:40 pm

I fully agree with you .Congratulations on sharing such a detailed post. Many thanks for sharing this lovely post. Have a super nice day.

Reply
Assignment Help link
1/29/2018 01:49:45 am

looking for assignment help? if yes then ask us any help any time.

Reply
Custom Essay Writer link
1/29/2018 04:44:36 am

Wow, this is a great post and I would like to know more about the collection you are presenting here. Sure to follow you on Instagram too.

Reply
Assignment Help link
2/2/2018 02:36:32 am

Assignment Help, the quality writing service providers from expert firms.

Reply
Essay Writer UK link
2/11/2018 10:47:11 pm

wondering for best writing service? then hire best essay writer from UK

Reply
Assignment Help link
2/16/2018 05:38:47 am

Assignment Help from skilled writers online

Reply
UK Assignment Help link
3/10/2018 05:19:45 am

impressive work such a talented writer you are keep it up.

Reply
Online Assignment Help link
4/16/2018 02:37:15 am

nice post, thank you for sharing

Reply
Excellent Assignment Help link
5/22/2018 04:04:38 am

Helpful material. Thanks for sharing. Assignment writing help service.
<a href="https://www.excellentassignmenthelp.com.au"/>
Assignment Writing Help Service</a>

Reply
Buy Dissertation Online link
5/31/2018 05:12:02 am

This is true that that supreme court is doing well and playing its best role in making things better for people. However, most of people needs to be aware of different laws.

Reply
Custom Essays link
12/4/2018 08:09:21 am

great blog for the readers I love the work that you shared.

Reply
MATLAB solutions link
9/7/2019 03:45:50 am

It’s good to share information with others. I am also sharing something very important for students seeking <a href="https://www.matlabsolutions.com/matlab-assignment-help.php">MATLAB Assignment Help</a>. Visit MatlabSolutions and get best assistance in your MATLAB, Simulink Assignments and Projects.

You can also get <a href="https://cdrreportsaustralia.com/">CDR Report Engineers Australia</a> if you look to immigrate to Australia.

Reply
myassignmentmart link
9/22/2019 04:31:44 am

Sharing information with others is good. I also want to share some good links for students all across the world. There is a team providing assignment help , which includes writing help service in different subjects. Like as Mechanical Engineering Assignment Help,Electronics Engineering Assignment Help,MATLAB Assignment Help, Civil Engineering Assignment Help,Computer Science Assignment Help.

Reply
Enwapame Lee link
5/14/2020 02:58:51 am

Excellent information Providing by your Article, thank you for taking the time to share with us such a nice article. Amazing insight you have on this. Cryptocurrency is a new age of money, If you want to invest money in bitcoin then here <i><b><a href="https://www.cryptoknowmics.com/news/will-the-price-of-bitcoin-be-worth-by-2021">right time to invest in bitcoin.</a></b></i>

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Disclaimer: 
    All blog posts represent the views of the guest blogger, and are not necessarily representative of the larger coalition of organizations that support Congressional redistricting reform.

    This site is paid for by the League of Women Voters of Ohio,  100 E. Broad St., Suite # 1310, Columbus, OH 43215. To contact the League, please call 614-469-1505.
    ​

    Archives

    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    March 2019
    December 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • Take the End Gerrymandering Pledge
  • About
  • What is Gerrymandering?
  • Media
  • Events
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Voter Registration
  • Request a Speaker
  • Resources
  • History of Reform
  • Endorsements
  • Privacy Policy